Events and Documentation

Anti-Tory Protest: Injustice and detainment

A couple of days ago I, along with some other photographers, travelled to central London to document an unplanned protest following the recent re-election of a conservative Prime Minister.

I knew that there was going to be a considerable level of tension and anger present during the demonstration as many across the nation have been infuriated by what many consider to be an injustice in the voting system. However, we found nothing in the way of open aggression and violence when we first caught up with the moving crowd of protesters heading towards parliament square, many were smiling and happy…a very positive atmosphere allowing peaceful protesters to express their voice as one people.

The crowd reached parliament and had a small rest on the grass in front of the iconic building, I photographed a beautiful Staffordshire bull-pup and witnessed yet more positivity and peaceful protest. Of course there were many elements to the protest that were less than tasteful such as multiple signs using questionable language and many chants such as ‘Tory tory tory, scum scum scum’ and ‘David Cameron fuck off back to Eton’. Though these may not help to defeat the stereotypes linked to protesters, you have to accept that the public here have good reason to feel that certain words are the only means of expression that can give their feelings true justice. The crowd then moved onto Westminster bridge and back again before heading onto Downing Street, all the time maintaining the peace and ensuring the safety of everyone present.

Once we reached the gates of Downing Street, the protesters were met by rows of police behind metal barricades alongside riot vans waiting in preparation for what inevitably was to come next. The chants continued and protesters held their signs of disgust up high. Shouts of anger and frustration aimed at number 10 were spat from all sides yet still no one lifted a finger to harm anyone. We continued to take photographs of peaceful protest and laughed at some of the comical signs held, my personal favourites were the more minimalist ones displaying simple messages such as ‘Bull Shit’ and ‘Fuck You’. Though the frustration and anger was clear to all, there was still no attempt at violence from the crowd.

I was standing at the front with my camera when the fighting broke out. From what I could see, police officers were being too harsh and forceful with those closest to the barricades. I myself was shouted at and commanded by an officer to back away from the barrier, the officer also shoved me hard in the chest back into the crowd. From what I could tell, this unnecessary aggressive and forceful behaviour from the police helped to ignite and aggravate the already angry crowd, they reacted and pushed back. Objects and signs were seized and dragged away by officers of the law, then so were people. Officers ran around the barriers and started to drag protesters to the floor whilst threatening innocent protesters around them to stay back. I had a safe vantage point after I moved back away from the violence where I could see some of the arrests that happened during the first few moments of the outbreak. One woman, wearing a mask, was verbally challenging officers for their sudden aggression to which they responded by dragging her out of the crowd and pushing her into the barrier. Once she realised that she was being arrested she simply stood still and peacefully allowed them to restrain her with handcuffs, she was not fighting back or resisting in anyway yet the officer holding her forcefully tore her mask off of her face, forced her throat into the barrier, dragged her to the other side and proceeded to violently push her face down onto the concrete ground. Many people around me shouted out at this, warning the officers that they had seen this brutal treatment of innocent men and women. To this, the officers only responded with yet more threats, forcing us all to move back by brandishing batons and threatening to attack if we did not move. Smoke bombs flew from the crowd and into the police, objects were thrown from angry protesters, the air was filled with the chanting of ‘Shame on you! Shame on you!’.

I didn’t see many more of the arrests, the street was too consumed in green smoke to see much farther ahead but I did witness another officer threaten a foreign cyclist with what sounded like almost murderous intent. Obviously I doubt he actually meant what he said but an officer of the law should not be threatening people so brutally. Again, a nearby protester heard this and informed the officer as such. Though the media would have you believe that the fighting was controlled and ceased by the valiant and brave riot police, the reality is that the fighting stopped because a number of the protesters were rounding everybody back to the front and pleading with them to ‘keep the peace’. From my frontline perspective, the Police started the violence and the protesters ended it.

By this point, officers in riot gear had lined up in front of the gates to Downing Street and also further up the street towards Trafalgar Square. The protesters had been split and the riot officers were attempting to keep it that way. We moved further up the street to get away from officers driving us all back from Downing Street still brandishing batons in a threatening manner. On our way up I spotted and photographed the words ‘Fuck Tory Scum’ sprayed onto a war memorial, I knew at that instant that the right wing press would have exactly what they need to paint the protest in the worst possible light…that the rest of this highly peaceful protest was all for nothing. Slowly, the two formations of officers closed in on the group of protesters we were with and ‘kettled’ us. For those who don’t know, this is where riot squads surround a group of protesters and detain them in order to break apart and control a larger crowd.

Before the kettle was complete, I asked officers which was the best way out if there was still time, I was told by two officers to try the opposite side as we may still have time to leave. We found no luck, we tried an officer towards the side closest to Trafalgar. This man was the single most rude person I have ever encountered. I calmly asked if there was still time for us to leave to which he replied in a very aggressive tone ‘No! Back away! You’ve been given plenty of warning to get out, you’re being detained by the police for disturbing the peace!’. I explained to the officer that I was a neutral photographer, I was not part of the protest and I was simply documenting it, I had done nothing wrong and there was no need for him to speak to me like that. He continued to speak to me aggressively accusing me of biased coverage, that I wouldn’t have photographed the graffiti on the war memorial. I told him that I had…he told me to grow up. At that moment I realised why violence broke out, officers like this man have no patience and clearly believe that protests are their time to shine, as though they’re on the set of Hot Fuzz. It’s the brash and undisciplined nature of these brutish thugs in the Police service that aggravate crowds in the first place and their inability to remain calm is what keeps the fires burning. In all fairness to the police however, there were examples of officers who did try to remain calm and try so desperately hard to maintain the peace. Some officers shared laughs with the detained and answered any and all questions asked of them with a calm and supportive nature. It’s a shame they weren’t all so friendly, maybe violence wouldn’t have been the answer in which case.

During our detainment was when I witnessed first hand the power of media during times of social division, how the right wing press work in conservative favour to batter the representation of working classes. We were detained for a total of three hours, this is a long time for anyone to be held by intimidating riot police in one small space with a large crowd of unfamiliar people. To help raise spirits, many of the protesters in the kettle started playing instruments, others danced, some told jokes and put smiles on all faces including that of a girl who couldn’t have been older than thirteen. When we grew hungry and thirsty, people shared what food and water they had with everyone present. They were peaceful, happy and full of joy. Yet not one lens belonging to the mainstream media camera crews up and down the street was filming it, not one. We sat and watched as they filmed what very little fighting was taking place further down the street knowing that would be our representation later that night on the news. This is why I grabbed my camera again and started to photograph the positivity and sharing nature our small group was displaying, I knew the media would completely fail to share our example with the rest of the world so I had to do something to combat this.

Eventually, after three long hours, we were informed that we were allowed to leave. The Police formed a human corridor at one side of the kettle and allowed us to leave two at a time, it was a very surreal experience to walk down a corridor of riot gear officers…reminded me of the Matrix, soulless and menacing. Once we were out, we headed home. I turned on the TV to see what coverage had been on the news and of course, as predicted, the media focused on nothing but the graffiti on the memorial, one small element of a mostly peaceful march. Nothing was shown of the rest of the day, nothing was shown of the peace, the singing, the dancing. Only what little violence occurred and the war memorial. I was disgusted.

To those who believe the media, wake up…don’t believe everything you hear from Murdoch’s biased coverage. Take it from a man who was there, those who chose to express their voice that day did so peacefully with no intention of violence. The law enforcers enforced too heavily and brutally. The media focused only on what was negative and not on the music and sharing. They didn’t show a woman being needlessly dragged to the floor face first, they didn’t show a young teenage girl detained by riot police. They show only what they want you to see. It’s up to you to look further than your TV screens and the photographs they print in right wing papers.

I documented the day from start to finish, please view the day from an unbiased perspective. My lens tells no lies and hides no secrets. See the side you ought to see, not just what Murdoch fools you into believing is true.

Thank you.

J

Anti-Tory Protest-1 Anti-Tory Protest-2 Anti-Tory Protest-3 Anti-Tory Protest-4 Anti-Tory Protest-5 Anti-Tory Protest-6 Anti-Tory Protest-7 Anti-Tory Protest-8 Anti-Tory Protest-9 Anti-Tory Protest-10 Anti-Tory Protest-11 Anti-Tory Protest-12 Anti-Tory Protest-13 Anti-Tory Protest-14 Anti-Tory Protest-15 Anti-Tory Protest-16 Anti-Tory Protest-17 Anti-Tory Protest-18 Anti-Tory Protest-19 Anti-Tory Protest-20 Anti-Tory Protest-21 Anti-Tory Protest-22 Anti-Tory Protest-23 Anti-Tory Protest-24 Anti-Tory Protest-25 Anti-Tory Protest-26 Anti-Tory Protest-27 Anti-Tory Protest-28 Anti-Tory Protest-29 Anti-Tory Protest-30 Anti-Tory Protest-31 Anti-Tory Protest-32 Anti-Tory Protest-33 Anti-Tory Protest-34 Anti-Tory Protest-35 Anti-Tory Protest-36 Anti-Tory Protest-37 Anti-Tory Protest-38 Anti-Tory Protest-39 Anti-Tory Protest-40 Anti-Tory Protest-41 Anti-Tory Protest-42 Anti-Tory Protest-43 Anti-Tory Protest-44 Anti-Tory Protest-45 Anti-Tory Protest-46 Anti-Tory Protest-47 Anti-Tory Protest-48 Anti-Tory Protest-49 Anti-Tory Protest-50 Anti-Tory Protest-51 Anti-Tory Protest-52 Anti-Tory Protest-53 Anti-Tory Protest-54 Anti-Tory Protest-55 Anti-Tory Protest-56 Anti-Tory Protest-57 Anti-Tory Protest-58 Anti-Tory Protest-59 Anti-Tory Protest-60 Anti-Tory Protest-61 Anti-Tory Protest-62 Anti-Tory Protest-63 Anti-Tory Protest-64 Anti-Tory Protest-65 Anti-Tory Protest-66 Anti-Tory Protest-67 Anti-Tory Protest-68 Anti-Tory Protest-69 Anti-Tory Protest-70 Anti-Tory Protest-71 Anti-Tory Protest-72 Anti-Tory Protest-73 Anti-Tory Protest-74 Anti-Tory Protest-75 Anti-Tory Protest-76 Anti-Tory Protest-77 Anti-Tory Protest-78 Anti-Tory Protest-79 Anti-Tory Protest-80 Anti-Tory Protest-81 Anti-Tory Protest-82 Anti-Tory Protest-83 Anti-Tory Protest-84 Anti-Tory Protest-85 Anti-Tory Protest-86 Anti-Tory Protest-87 Anti-Tory Protest-88 Anti-Tory Protest-89 Anti-Tory Protest-90 Anti-Tory Protest-91 Anti-Tory Protest-92 Anti-Tory Protest-93 Anti-Tory Protest-94 Anti-Tory Protest-95 Anti-Tory Protest-96 Anti-Tory Protest-97 Anti-Tory Protest-98 Anti-Tory Protest-99 Anti-Tory Protest-100 Anti-Tory Protest-101 Anti-Tory Protest-102 Anti-Tory Protest-103 Anti-Tory Protest-104 Anti-Tory Protest-105 Anti-Tory Protest-106 Anti-Tory Protest-107 Anti-Tory Protest-108 Anti-Tory Protest-109 Anti-Tory Protest-110 Anti-Tory Protest-111 Anti-Tory Protest-112 Anti-Tory Protest-113 Anti-Tory Protest-114 Anti-Tory Protest-115 Anti-Tory Protest-116 Anti-Tory Protest-117 Anti-Tory Protest-118 Anti-Tory Protest-119 Anti-Tory Protest-120 Anti-Tory Protest-121 Anti-Tory Protest-122 Anti-Tory Protest-123 Anti-Tory Protest-124 Anti-Tory Protest-125 Anti-Tory Protest-126 Anti-Tory Protest-127 Anti-Tory Protest-128 Anti-Tory Protest-129 Anti-Tory Protest-130 Anti-Tory Protest-131 Anti-Tory Protest-132 Anti-Tory Protest-133 Anti-Tory Protest-134 Anti-Tory Protest-135 Anti-Tory Protest-136 Anti-Tory Protest-137 Anti-Tory Protest-138 Anti-Tory Protest-139 Anti-Tory Protest-140 Anti-Tory Protest-141 Anti-Tory Protest-142 Anti-Tory Protest-143 Anti-Tory Protest-144 Anti-Tory Protest-145 Anti-Tory Protest-146 Anti-Tory Protest-147 Anti-Tory Protest-148 Anti-Tory Protest-149 Anti-Tory Protest-150 Anti-Tory Protest-151 Anti-Tory Protest-152 Anti-Tory Protest-153 Anti-Tory Protest-154 Anti-Tory Protest-155 Anti-Tory Protest-156 Anti-Tory Protest-157 Anti-Tory Protest-158 Anti-Tory Protest-159 Anti-Tory Protest-160 Anti-Tory Protest-161 Anti-Tory Protest-162 Anti-Tory Protest-163 Anti-Tory Protest-164 Anti-Tory Protest-165 Anti-Tory Protest-166 Anti-Tory Protest-167 Anti-Tory Protest-168 Anti-Tory Protest-169 Anti-Tory Protest-170 Anti-Tory Protest-171 Anti-Tory Protest-172 Anti-Tory Protest-173 Anti-Tory Protest-174 Anti-Tory Protest-175 Anti-Tory Protest-176 Anti-Tory Protest-177 Anti-Tory Protest-178 Anti-Tory Protest-179 Anti-Tory Protest-180 Anti-Tory Protest-181 Anti-Tory Protest-182 Anti-Tory Protest-183 Anti-Tory Protest-184 Anti-Tory Protest-185 Anti-Tory Protest-186 Anti-Tory Protest-187 Anti-Tory Protest-188 Anti-Tory Protest-189 Anti-Tory Protest-190 Anti-Tory Protest-191 Anti-Tory Protest-192 Anti-Tory Protest-193 Anti-Tory Protest-194 Anti-Tory Protest-195 Anti-Tory Protest-196 Anti-Tory Protest-197 Anti-Tory Protest-198 Anti-Tory Protest-199 Anti-Tory Protest-200 Anti-Tory Protest-201 Anti-Tory Protest-202 Anti-Tory Protest-203 Anti-Tory Protest-204 Anti-Tory Protest-205 Anti-Tory Protest-206 Anti-Tory Protest-207 Anti-Tory Protest-208 Anti-Tory Protest-209 Anti-Tory Protest-210 Anti-Tory Protest-211 Anti-Tory Protest-212 Anti-Tory Protest-213 Anti-Tory Protest-214 Anti-Tory Protest-215

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Anti-Tory Protest: Injustice and detainment

  1. I’ve worked with the police in many an educational environment and just like there will be factions of protestors intent on violence and provocative behaviour the same exists with the police. Of course it shouldn’t be that way as policing should be about protecting people but basically some elements of the police such as those who might have hung-around with the likes of PC Harwood look forward to a good riot, are provocative, aggressive, get turned on by the thought of it and use discourse and rhetoric that legitimises their behaviour to themselves and those who would wish to be part of their sub-group. This allows them to see protestors as a ‘them’ out-group…why those who would ‘manage’ the police cannot work on this aspect to eradicate it seems to suggest it is systemic in the police-force and therefore allowed under whatever umbrella deemed acceptable at the time. I have no confidence in riot police…they are there to practice their rioting skills it only takes a small faction to make it start from protestors or police. All we can do is document it and bring the truth to public knowledge especially where mainstream journalism repeatedly fails to do this.

    • Of course you are right my friend but there were examples of friendly officers as well. It’s just a shame there weren’t more at that day that don’t feel the need for violence and aggression. I’ve spoken to too many people who believe police should be aggressive and intimidating otherwise they can’t be good at their job. This is a ridiculous claim, the aggressive a did nothing but further aggravate the angry crowd whereas the few officers who remained calm and used words and reason in a friendly manner did a far better job of keeping protesters calm. I witnessed first hand that intimidation, threats and aggression just does not work.

      • Thats my point some officers remained calm and did a far better job of ‘policing’ but other officers found legitimacy in being aggressive, angry and confrontational. It is these officers one needs to focus on a bit and questions such as where do they find the legitimacy to behave that way…take their uniforms away from them and they would still be aggressive but we’d call them thugs and not police officers. They find the legitimacy in a system of police management that does not wheedle out that kind of rot and by passively allowing it some officers will see that as a green light for that behaviour. But the other point made in the piece is that mainstream journalism doesn’t film passive protesting it seems only interested in the violence and is keen to angle blame usually at protestors.

      • This is why I was so frustrated at the demonstration and the media/public response to what happened. Changes are in dire need of being made in many elements of our country and government but not enough people are making the effort to identify the problems. Why question unreasonable police brutality when you can simply accept that as the norm? Why question the absence of balanced and fair media coverage when you can just believe only what they show you already? Right wing press doesn’t cover peaceful protesting because it isn’t in the best interest of the right wing. Negatively representing socialists and opposition of the right wing is in favour of Murdoch and his conservative friends therefore they do. The problem is not only is this issue in effect but also in the fact that the public are doing nothing about it.

  2. Pingback: The Play, The Protest and The Song | Mummy Shambles

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s